If you’re planning a move to Brooklyn, you’re likely weighing the choice between an apartment and one of the borough’s legendary brownstones. These charming structures are woven into the fabric of Brooklyn’s history. Yet, for all their beauty and character, brownstones come with a lifestyle and logistical experience very different from that of a modern apartment.
In this guide, we’ll explore everything you need to know about moving in a Brooklyn brownstone house, including the pros and cons, lifestyle differences, and what to expect inside one of these iconic homes. If you’re stuck choosing between character or convenience, this article is for you.
What Is a Brownstone House?
First, let’s clarify what a brownstone house is. A brownstone is a style of townhouse made from brown sandstone, a material that gained popularity in New York City during the 19th century. You’ll find rows of these homes lining the streets of neighborhoods like Park Slope, Cobble Hill, and Clinton Hill.
These homes are usually three to five stories tall, featuring a stoop that leads up to the parlor level. They are a defining feature of many classic Brooklyn neighborhoods and are considered historic landmarks by many residents and architecture lovers.
What to Expect Inside a Brownstone House
When you step inside a brownstone house, you’ll be greeted by high ceilings, original crown moldings, and elegant hardwood floors. Many also have grand staircases, fireplaces, and bay windows that flood rooms with natural light.
But these homes aren’t just beautiful—they’re quirky too. You might find narrow hallways, oddly shaped rooms, or outdated fixtures. It’s part of the charm. But keep in mind, these features might require upgrades or remodeling if you plan to live there long-term.
The Unique Challenge of Moving in a Brooklyn Brownstone House
Let’s talk about the actual move. Moving in a Brooklyn brownstone house can be a serious challenge if you’re not prepared. These buildings rarely have elevators and often have narrow, steep staircases.
Trying to carry a large couch or bed up several flights of stairs is no easy task.
That’s why many locals turn to a trusted Brooklyn Moving Company that knows how to handle these tricky moves. Professionals familiar with brownstone moves will know how to navigate tight turns and safely move your belongings without damaging the historical features of your new home.
The Brownstone Lifestyle vs. Apartment Living
Living in a brownstone feels completely different from life in an apartment building. Brownstone living gives you space, character, and a stronger connection to the neighborhood. Many brownstones come with private gardens or rooftop access, offering rare outdoor space in the city.
Apartment life, on the other hand, is usually about convenience. Many modern buildings offer elevators, doormen, fitness centers, and laundry rooms. You won’t get as much character, but you’ll save time and energy with the added amenities.
Are Brownstones Expensive?
One of the most common questions is: Are brownstones expensive? And yes—they typically are. Buying a brownstone in popular neighborhoods like Carroll Gardens or Brooklyn Heights can set you back several million dollars.
Even renting a unit in a brownstone may be pricier than a comparable apartment. The historic charm and space come at a premium. However, the long-term investment potential can be worth it, especially in a competitive market like Brooklyn.
Buying a Brownstone in NYC: What You Need to Know
If you’re thinking of buying a brownstone in NYC, you’re not alone. Many people are drawn to the timeless appeal of these homes. But be aware—it’s not just the purchase price you’ll need to budget for older brownstones often need renovations.
From plumbing to electrical upgrades, these costs can add up. Still, for those who can afford it, owning a brownstone is like owning a living piece of history. And many buyers offset their mortgage by renting out a floor or two—a common strategy in Brooklyn.
Inside the Community
One of the benefits of brownstone living is the tight-knit, community feel. You’ll see your neighbors on the stoop, at the park, or at the corner coffee shop. Many of these neighborhoods feel like small towns within the big city.
Apartments, especially in high-rises, can feel more anonymous. You might never meet the person living next door. Depending on your lifestyle, that can be a pro or a con. If you’re social, brownstones offer a more connected experience.
Renovation Realities
Living in a historic home can be beautiful, but it’s not always easy. If you’re moving in a Brooklyn brownstone house, be ready for the potential of repairs and upgrades. Some homes still have original heating systems or outdated kitchens and bathrooms.
Renovating can be rewarding, but time-consuming and costly. Be sure to consult with professionals who specialize in historic properties so you don’t damage the home’s original features or violate local preservation rules.
Space and Layout Comparison
Brownstones tend to be larger than apartments. You might get two or three full floors, a backyard, and even a basement. This makes brownstones a great option for families or those working from home.
Apartments, by comparison, are more compact. However, the layout is often more efficient and requires less upkeep. If you want a lot of space and don’t mind the maintenance, brownstones are a great fit.
Maintenance Differences
Maintenance is a big factor to consider. Brownstone owners are responsible for everything—roof leaks, boiler issues, snow removal—you name it.
In an apartment building, those headaches are handled by property management. But you’ll often pay a monthly fee for the convenience. If you want more control and don’t mind the work, a brownstone is perfect. If you’d rather have someone else handle it, stick with an apartment.
Property Value and Long-Term Investment
When it comes to long-term value, buying a brownstone in NYC can be a great investment. Because of their limited supply and timeless appeal, brownstones often appreciate faster than modern apartments.
Neighborhoods full of brownstones tend to retain value even during market dips. Apartments can also appreciate, but trends often depend on building condition, management, and nearby development.
Accessibility Concerns
One of the biggest downsides of brownstones is accessibility. If you or a family member has mobility issues, a home without an elevator and with steep steps may not be suitable.
Most newer apartment buildings in Brooklyn are built with elevators and ADA-compliant features. Be sure to consider this carefully if accessibility is a concern.
Should You Choose a Brownstone or an Apartment?
So, what’s the better choice? Moving in a Brooklyn brownstone house is perfect if you want space, charm, and a neighborhood feel. Brownstones offer rich history and personalization opportunities that apartments simply can’t match.
However, apartments win on convenience, maintenance, and accessibility. If you prefer a hassle-free lifestyle and love amenities, a well-located apartment is the smarter option.
Whichever you choose, hiring a reputable Brooklyn Moving Company will make the transition smoother. From navigating staircases to finding parking permits, they’ll handle the hard stuff so you can focus on settling in.
Final Thoughts
Choosing between a brownstone and an apartment in Brooklyn is a personal decision. Each comes with its own set of trade-offs. Whether you crave the charm and history of a brownstone or the modern perks of an apartment, there’s no wrong answer—just what fits your lifestyle best.
But one thing’s for sure: Brooklyn has no shortage of beautiful homes. Whether you’re buying a brownstone in NYC or signing a lease in a sleek new tower, you’re sure to fall in love with this borough’s culture, energy, and charm. And when you’re ready to move, don’t forget to team up with an experienced Brooklyn Moving Company to get the job done right.
