Choosing the perfect flooring for your home or commercial space can feel overwhelming. With so many products on the market, it’s easy to get lost in technical specifications, design options, and installation methods. Among the most trusted and widely recognised luxury vinyl tile (LVT) brands, two names often come up: Karndean and Amtico. Both offer a wide range of stylish, durable flooring solutions, but how do you know which one is right for your space?
In this guide, we’ll explore the key factors to consider when selecting between these two leading brands, helping you navigate their popular collections.
Understanding Luxury Vinyl Tile (LVT)
Before comparing specific collections, it’s important to understand what makes LVT such a popular flooring option. Luxury vinyl tile is designed to replicate the look and feel of natural materials, such as hardwood or stone, while offering superior durability, water resistance, and ease of maintenance.
LVT comes in a variety of designs, from traditional wood planks to sleek stone tiles. It’s suitable for almost every room in the home, including moisture-prone areas like kitchens and bathrooms. Many LVT products also feature built-in acoustic layers, making them quieter underfoot.
Key Considerations When Choosing LVT
When deciding between different LVT options, consider the following factors:
- Design and Aesthetics
Look for a range that complements your interior style. Whether you prefer rustic wood, modern stone, or abstract patterns, there are countless designs to choose from. - Durability and Wear Layer
The wear layer protects the surface from scratches, stains, and wear. Higher wear layers are recommended for busy households and commercial spaces. - Installation Type
LVT can be installed via glue-down or click-lock systems. Glue-down offers a more permanent solution, while click-lock is ideal for quicker DIY projects. - Room Usage
Consider the specific needs of each room. Bathrooms and kitchens require waterproof and slip-resistant options, while living areas may focus more on comfort and style.
Spotlight on Amtico Collections
The Amtico collections are known for their sophisticated designs and exceptional craftsmanship. Each range is tailored to suit specific design needs and practical requirements.
Amtio First
Ideal for budget-conscious homeowners or light commercial environments, Amtico First offers a selection of stylish, entry-level designs. This collection provides a balanced blend of durability and aesthetic appeal, making it a great choice for less demanding spaces like bedrooms or studies.
Thickness: 2mm, Wear Layer: 0.3mm
Amtico Spacia
A perfect combination of contemporary style and everyday functionality, Amtico Spacia is known for its extensive palette of wood and stone designs. It offers robust wear layers, making it suitable for high-traffic areas like hallways, kitchens and open-plan living spaces.
Thickness: 2.5mm, Wear Layer: 0.55mm
Amtico Form
For those seeking a handcrafted natural look, Amtico Form stands out with its textured finishes and timeless appeal. It works well in spaces where warmth and authenticity are key, such as dining rooms or cozy lounges.
Thickness: 2.5mm, Wear Layer: 0.7mm
Amtico Signature
The pinnacle of design freedom, Amtico Signature allows for complete customisation with an expansive array of laying patterns, borders, and motifs. It’s an excellent choice for those wanting a truly unique floor, perfect for statement areas or high-end interiors.
Thickness: 2.5mm, Wear Layer: 1.0mm
Spotlight on Karndean Collections
Karndean also offers an impressive range of LVT collections, each suited to various design schemes and performance requirements.
Karndean Knight Tile
Known for its versatility, Karndean Knight Tile features a broad spectrum of wood and stone designs. It’s an excellent option for homeowners seeking an affordable yet stylish floor that works across multiple rooms, from kitchens to hallways.
Thickness: 2.0mm, Wear Layer: 0.3mm
Karndean Van Gogh
For those who love the look of classic wood flooring, Karndean Van Gogh delivers larger planks with intricate grain details. It’s ideal for spaces where a bold, rustic aesthetic is desired—think family rooms or expansive open-plan areas.
Thickness: 2.5mm, Wear Layer: 0.55mm
Karndean Art Select
Offering the most refined and detailed visuals, Karndean Art Select is perfect for those looking to bring luxury and elegance into their space. With deeply embossed surfaces and sophisticated finishes, this collection excels in living rooms, master bedrooms, and other statement spaces.
Thickness: 2.5mm, Wear Layer: 0.7mm
Comparing Design Options
Both brands excel in offering an exceptional range of designs, but the difference lies in the execution and details. For subtle, classic tones and understated elegance, Amtico Spacia and Karndean Knight Tile are excellent choices. If you’re after dramatic textures and bolder visuals, Amtico Form and Karndean Van Gogh offer standout options.
For customisation lovers, Amtico Signature and Karnedan Art Select present the opportunity to create intricate patterns and premium looks. These collections allow for more elaborate designs, including borders, motifs, and personalised layouts.
Liked what you read? This related post is another hidden gem.
Durability and Wear Layer Considerations
When it comes to wear layers, both brands cater to different needs. Amtico First and Karndean Knight Tile are suited for residential environments with moderate foot traffic. The other ranges from both brands are designed with thicker wear layers, making them suitable in a domestic or commercial environment.
Installation Methods
Both brands offer flexible installation methods, from glue-down to click-lock systems. Collections like Karndean Van Gogh Rigid Core and Karndean Knight Tile Rigid Core are click options that are suitable for DIYers, while the other ranges from both brands are glue down and are best installed by professionals to ensure precision.
Your choice will depend on whether you prioritise speed and convenience or long-term performance and stability.
Pricing and Value
While exact pricing varies depending on the retailer and specific product chosen, there are general trends worth noting.
First and Knight Tile are among the most budget-friendly options, making them accessible for projects with tighter budgets. Mid-range collections such as Spacia, and Van Gogh deliver excellent value for money, offering enhanced durability alongside sophisticated design.
High-end collections like Form, Signature and Art Select sit at the premium end of the spectrum, reflecting their advanced features and customisation possibilities.
Maintenance and Longevity
LVT from both brands is low maintenance, requiring only regular sweeping and occasional mopping. Stain resistance, water resistance, and scratch protection are consistent across most collections, ensuring longevity in everyday use.
For those seeking maximum lifespan and warranty coverage, higher-spec collections such as Signature and Art Select provide extended warranties and superior resilience.
Which One is Right for You?
Ultimately, the choice comes down to your personal style, practical requirements, and budget. All of the ranges from both brands are suitable in a domestic environment from wear layer perspective, it is important to select a colour and laying pattern that you are happy with, if you find this in one of the entry price points it’s a bonus for sure!
Here’s a quick summary:
- For budget-friendly solutions: Consider First or Knight Tile
- For versatile, all-round performers: Explore Spacia or Van Gogh
- For high-end luxury and custom design: Look at Form, Signature or Art Select
Each collection brings its own unique benefits, ensuring there’s an option to suit every home or project.
Final Thoughts
Selecting the right LVT isn’t just about picking a pretty design, it’s about understanding your space, lifestyle, and long-term needs. Whether you’re creating a family-friendly kitchen, a sophisticated lounge, or a stylish bathroom retreat, the right floor can completely transform your environment.
By weighing design options, durability, installation, and budget, you can confidently choose an LVT that not only enhances your décor but also stands the test of time.
In the end, both brands offer exceptional solutions—and no matter which direction you take, you’ll enjoy the perfect blend of style, practicality, and lasting value underfoot.
If you enjoyed this post, you’ll love what’s featured on 2A Magazine.
