Difference Between Statutory Audit and Stock Audit in India

Hero Benefits:

Clear understanding of both audit types and their purposes

Know which audit applies to your business requirements

Comprehensive comparison across key parameters

Understanding Statutory Audit vs Stock Audit

Audits form the backbone of corporate governance and financial transparency in India. However, different types of audits serve distinct purposes, and understanding these differences helps businesses maintain appropriate compliance. Two commonly confused audit types are statutory audit and stock audit, each addressing fundamentally different aspects of business operations.

While statutory audit examines the overall financial statements of a company to verify their accuracy and compliance with accounting standards, Stock Audit in India focuses specifically on verifying physical inventory against recorded book values. The distinction matters because each audit serves different stakeholders, follows separate regulatory frameworks, and requires distinct expertise from the auditors conducting them.

This guide provides a detailed comparison between these two audit types, helping business owners, finance professionals, and compliance officers understand when each audit applies and what it entails. Whether you’re a manufacturing company with significant inventory holdings or a service enterprise focused primarily on financial compliance, clarity on these audit requirements ensures you meet all regulatory obligations effectively.

What is Statutory Audit?

A statutory audit is a legally mandated examination of a company’s financial statements to determine whether they present a true and fair view of its financial position. Governed primarily by the Companies Act, 2013 in India, this audit is compulsory for all registered companies regardless of their size, turnover, or nature of business. The term ‘statutory’ itself indicates that this audit is required by statute or law.

The primary objective of statutory audit is to provide assurance to shareholders, investors, creditors, and regulatory authorities that the financial statements accurately reflect the company’s financial health. The auditor examines balance sheets, profit and loss accounts, cash flow statements, and supporting records to verify that accounting entries are genuine, properly classified, and compliant with applicable accounting standards such as Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS) or IFRS.

Only qualified Chartered Accountants or CA firms registered with the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) can conduct statutory audits. The auditor is appointed by shareholders at the Annual General Meeting and reports directly to them, maintaining independence from the company’s management. This independence ensures objectivity in assessing whether financial statements are free from material misstatements, whether due to fraud or error.

Top pick of the week—insights that are too good to scroll past.

What is Stock Audit?

A stock audit is an independent verification process that compares physical inventory with book records to ensure accuracy and identify discrepancies. Unlike statutory audit which examines entire financial statements, Stock Audit in India concentrates exclusively on inventory, including raw materials, work-in-progress, finished goods, and consumables. This specialised examination helps organisations maintain control over their most significant current assets.

The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) mandates stock audits for borrowers with credit facilities exceeding prescribed limits, typically Rs. 5 crore or more. Banks and financial institutions rely on stock audit reports to assess the security of their loans, as inventory often serves as collateral for working capital facilities. Beyond regulatory requirements, many organisations voluntarily conduct Stock Audit in India to strengthen internal controls and detect pilferage, wastage, or recording errors.

Stock auditors visit warehouses, factories, and storage locations to physically count inventory items, verify their condition, check valuation methods (FIFO, LIFO, or weighted average), and reconcile findings with accounting records. The audit identifies slow-moving or obsolete stock, damaged goods, and discrepancies that require adjustment. Industries with high-value or fast-moving inventory, such as manufacturing, retail, pharmaceuticals, and automotive, particularly benefit from regular stock audits.

Key Differences Between Statutory Audit and Stock Audit

Understanding the fundamental differences between these audit types helps businesses allocate resources appropriately and meet specific compliance requirements. The following sections examine the major distinguishing factors.

Objective and Purpose

Statutory audit aims to verify the truthfulness and fairness of overall financial statements. It provides assurance that accounting records comply with legal requirements and present an accurate picture of the company’s financial position to external stakeholders. The audit covers all aspects of financial reporting, including revenues, expenses, assets, liabilities, and equity.

Stock Audit in India, conversely, focuses narrowly on inventory verification. Its purpose is ensuring that physical stock matches recorded quantities, that inventory is properly valued, and that internal controls over stock management are adequate. The audit serves operational efficiency goals alongside compliance requirements for lenders.

Legal Framework and Applicability

Statutory audit is mandated under the Companies Act, 2013 for all companies registered in India. Every private limited company, public limited company, and one-person company must undergo annual statutory audit regardless of turnover or profitability. LLPs with turnover exceeding Rs. 40 lakh or contribution exceeding Rs. 25 lakh also require statutory audit.

Stock audit requirements stem from RBI guidelines for bank borrowers and internal policies of lending institutions. It becomes mandatory when working capital facilities exceed specified thresholds. Manufacturing units, trading businesses, and any organisation with significant inventory holdings may face stock audit requirements from their bankers.

Auditor Qualifications

Statutory audit can only be conducted by practising Chartered Accountants holding a Certificate of Practice from ICAI. The Companies Act specifically disqualifies certain persons, including company employees, relatives of directors, and those with financial interests in the company. The auditor must maintain complete independence from management.

Stock audit may be conducted by Chartered Accountants, Cost Accountants, or professionals with relevant expertise in inventory management. While CAs commonly perform Stock Audit in India, the regulatory requirements are less stringent regarding auditor qualifications compared to statutory audit. Banks may specify preferred qualifications in their sanction letters.

Frequency and Timing

Statutory audit occurs annually, conducted after the close of each financial year. The audit must be completed before the Annual General Meeting where shareholders receive the audited financial statements. Companies typically have six months from the financial year-end to hold their AGM.

Stock audit frequency varies based on bank requirements and business needs. Banks may mandate quarterly, half-yearly, or annual stock audits depending on credit exposure and perceived risk. Some organisations conduct monthly stock audits for high-value or fast-moving inventory items to maintain tighter control.

Statutory Audit vs Stock Audit: Comparison Table

When is Each Audit Required?

Statutory Audit Applicability

Every company registered under the Companies Act, 2013 must undergo statutory audit annually. This includes private limited companies, public limited companies, one-person companies, and Section 8 companies irrespective of turnover, profit, or business activity. The requirement is absolute with no exemptions based on company size.

Limited Liability Partnerships require statutory audit when annual turnover exceeds Rs. 40 lakh or partner contribution exceeds Rs. 25 lakh. Partnership firms and sole proprietorships don’t require statutory audit but may need tax audit under the Income Tax Act if turnover exceeds specified thresholds.

Stock Audit Applicability

Stock audit becomes mandatory when businesses avail working capital facilities from banks and the credit exposure exceeds RBI-prescribed limits, generally Rs. 5 crore or above. Individual banks may set lower thresholds based on their risk assessment policies. The requirement applies across business structures, whether company, LLP, partnership, or proprietorship.

Beyond mandatory requirements, businesses with high-value inventory, multiple warehouses, or complex supply chains often conduct voluntary stock audits. Manufacturing units, retail chains, pharmaceutical distributors, and automotive dealers find regular stock audits essential for operational efficiency regardless of bank mandates.

Documents Required for Each Audit

Statutory Audit Documentation

Financial statements including balance sheet, profit and loss account, and cash flow statement form the core documents. Auditors also require trial balance, general ledger, bank statements, bank reconciliation statements, invoices, receipts, tax filings, income tax returns, TDS certificates, fixed assets register, loan agreements, payroll records, and previous audit reports.

Stock Audit Documentation

Stock Audit in India requires updated stock ledger and valuation reports, warehouse layout plans, purchase and sales records including invoices and delivery challans, GRN copies, bank sanction letters, fixed assets register if applicable, ERP system access, stock movement records, valuation methodology documentation, list of obsolete or damaged stock, insurance policies, and management declarations.

Can the Same Auditor Conduct Both Audits?

Yes, the same Chartered Accountant or CA firm can conduct both statutory audit and stock audit for an organisation, provided no conflict of interest exists. However, many organisations prefer engaging different auditors for each function to ensure independent scrutiny and avoid over-reliance on a single professional’s judgment.

Banks sometimes specify that the stock auditor should be different from the statutory auditor to maintain objectivity. When inventory constitutes a significant portion of total assets, having separate auditors provides additional assurance to lenders about the accuracy of collateral valuations.

Conclusion

Statutory audit and stock audit serve complementary but distinct purposes in the corporate governance framework. While statutory audit provides a comprehensive assessment of financial statement accuracy for shareholders and regulators, stock audit specifically addresses inventory verification for operational efficiency and lender assurance. Understanding these differences enables businesses to meet compliance requirements efficiently and allocate audit resources appropriately.

For companies with significant inventory holdings, both audits become essential components of annual compliance. Statutory audit fulfils legal obligations under the Companies Act, while stock audit satisfies banking requirements and strengthens internal controls over valuable current assets. Together, these audits contribute to financial transparency, stakeholder confidence, and sustainable business operations.

Choosing qualified professionals for each audit type ensures thorough examination and reliable reporting. Whether engaging the same auditor for both functions or appointing separate professionals, the focus should remain on achieving accurate verification, identifying areas for improvement, and maintaining the highest standards of financial integrity.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the main difference between statutory audit and stock audit?

Statutory audit examines complete financial statements to verify their accuracy and compliance with accounting standards. Stock audit focuses specifically on verifying physical inventory against book records. Statutory audit is legally mandated for all companies, while stock audit is required primarily for bank borrowers.

2. Is statutory audit mandatory for all businesses in India?

Statutory audit is mandatory for all companies registered under the Companies Act, 2013, regardless of size or turnover. LLPs require statutory audit only when turnover exceeds Rs. 40 lakh or contribution exceeds Rs. 25 lakh. Proprietorships and partnerships don’t require statutory audit but may need tax audit.

3. When does stock audit become mandatory?

Stock audit becomes mandatory when bank credit facilities exceed RBI-prescribed thresholds, typically Rs. 5 crore. Individual banks may have different thresholds based on their policies. The requirement applies to businesses holding inventory as collateral for working capital loans.

4. Who can conduct statutory audit in India?

Only Chartered Accountants holding a Certificate of Practice from the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India can conduct statutory audit. The auditor must be independent and cannot be an employee, relative of directors, or have financial interest in the company.

5. Who can conduct stock audit?

Stock audit can be conducted by Chartered Accountants, Cost Accountants, or professionals with relevant expertise in inventory management. Requirements are less stringent than statutory audit, though banks may specify preferred qualifications in their sanction letters.

6. How often is statutory audit conducted?

Statutory audit is conducted annually after the close of each financial year. The audit must be completed before the Annual General Meeting, which should be held within six months from the financial year-end.

7. What is the frequency of stock audit?

Stock audit frequency depends on bank requirements and may be quarterly, half-yearly, or annual. Banks determine the frequency based on credit exposure and risk assessment. Businesses may also conduct additional stock audits voluntarily for internal control purposes.

8. Does statutory audit cover inventory verification?

Statutory audit includes inventory verification as part of overall asset examination, but typically on a sample basis. The statutory auditor verifies that inventory is properly valued and recorded in financial statements. Stock audit provides more detailed physical verification of all inventory items.

9. To whom is the statutory audit report submitted?

The statutory audit report is submitted to shareholders and presented at the Annual General Meeting. It’s also filed with the Registrar of Companies along with annual returns. The report becomes part of public record accessible to stakeholders and regulatory authorities.

10. Who receives the stock audit report?

Stock audit reports are submitted to the lending bank or financial institution that mandated the audit. Copies are also provided to company management for review and corrective action. Unlike statutory audit reports, stock audit reports are not filed with regulatory authorities.

11. Can a company need both statutory audit and stock audit?

Yes, many companies require both audits. Every registered company must undergo statutory audit as per the Companies Act. Additionally, if the company has bank borrowings exceeding threshold limits with inventory as collateral, Stock Audit in India also becomes mandatory. Manufacturing and trading companies commonly need both.

12. What happens if statutory audit or stock audit is not conducted?

Failure to conduct statutory audit attracts penalties under the Companies Act, including fines on the company and its officers. Non-compliance with Stock Audit in India requirements may lead banks to recall loans, reduce credit limits, or charge higher interest rates. Both non-compliances damage business credibility and regulatory standing.

Highlight of the month—read what’s making waves in your industry at 2A Magazine.